Week 7 - Language Blog
Although this assignment was relatively easy to accomplish, I
found it was rather difficult to find time to sit with one of my family members
and have them actively participate in helping me with my assignment. But once I
was able to partner up with my sister during a weeknight dinner, we both found that
it is fun and interesting to learn how language is much more complex than it seems.
It was very difficult to communicate without using my spoken
language. This is because I wasn’t able to express most of my ideas even though
we are allowed to use hand signals, body language, gestures and facial expressions.
However, my sister found it very entertaining that I was able to only react and
not necessarily contribute my own thoughts on the subjects she discussed to me.
She definitely took advantage of the fact that I couldn’t respond verbally and
that I showed so much restraint in actually blurting out what I was thinking. So
she did ultimately change the way she usually communicates with me since she
spoke a lot more about herself only because I couldn’t really talk about my day.
She did try to ask me questions to test how I would respond, but that ended
quickly when it got boring and my responses were insufficient.
It also was very difficult to communicate using language but
omitting the use of every other type of communication. Part two was definitely
my favorite part because it was so funny to explain my ideas without using
tone. I tried my best not to laugh because it was truly ridiculous to talk
about certain topics that demand use of an appropriate tone. I would speak my
normal self without any change in tone but It would just come off as robotic and
I sounded like the first-version of Siri. My partner initially didn’t alter the
way she spoke but ultimately she ended up mimicking my lack of tone to a certain
degree. In the end we found it hilariously awkward since she lessened her tone
so much and stopped using hand gestures almost automatically in order to mirror
my energy.
Throughout part one my partner had the most control of the
conversation. My responses were very limited to thumbs up, thumbs down,
frowning, grinning, head tilting, eyebrow raising, and throwing up hands in frustration.
She on the other hand, drove the conversation using all forms of communication
including hand gestures, facial expressions and changes in tone.
If my sister represents a culture that uses spoken language
and I represent a culture that doesn’t, that means she has most of the power
without a doubt. Just like how my sister took advantage of my inability to
speak at the moment, I feel that a culture that uses spoken language would
naturally do the same to a culture that doesn’t use spoken language. There is
this underlying lack of respect and consideration to a culture that is unable
to express themselves using spoken language.
In part two, she was very comfortable in speaking in her
normal self but as the conversation progressed, she started to subconsciously mirror
my lack of tone, facial expressions, and hand gestures. In the end, we both sat
across from each other with our hands on our laps, flat facial expression, monotone
voice, and growing awkward silence. So part two gave me a lot more power than
in part one. I was the one who drove the atmosphere of the conversation to say
the least.
Non-speech language is very important in conveying deeper
meaning that spoken language fails to express by itself. Without using body
language, you pose a sort of threat to the other person because they are unable
to read your intentions and feelings. This is due to acquired experience that
teaches us to trust those who express themselves in a honest way and that way
we can know if they are dangerous or trustworthy.
Being able to effectively read body language can inevitably
save your life because as we’ve learn through this experiment, it conveys
deeper meaning than just listening to words. We’ve all experienced times where you
feel unsure to trust someone based on something they said or maybe how they said
it. You can obtain resources by changing your tone and using the right gestures
and facial expressions to gain the trust of another person. To reproduce successfully,
a person has to show that they have survival skills which may mean that he or
she needs to be able to obtain resources through effective communication skills.
There are people who lie within the autistic spectrum who may
have a hard time understanding regular people because they don’t have the
ability to recognize emotions, or discern between positive and negative
feelings of other people. They might also have a hard time conveying their
message by not understanding how to change their tone or use proper non-speech
techniques that help other people understand them as well. There is the issue
of different culture also being uable to communicate with each other due to
language barriers that include hand gestures as well as spoken language.
Another obstacle would be cultural backgrounds which determine how one tends to
express themselves to other people.
Hi Julissa,
ReplyDeleteIt was really nice reading you blog post because it resonated so much with my experience and results after having performed this exercise. I myself had a hard time with part A but somehow part B was even more difficult to perform because my partner and I couldn't help but laugh nearly through the entire thing. I can image how silly we would all look if everyone talked without a variation of tone and no expression. Reading the last part of your post made me realize how something so simple can become such a hard task to do for people we know about. I wrote about blind and deaf people and it's humbling to try and put myself in their shoes and imagine what life is like without precious attributes such as our voice, our sight, or being able to read body language. I'm sure people adjust but i'm also sure that majority of us people who are fortunate to have these attributes can be mean enough to push people aside. Sometimes we forget to be inclusive of everyone. This assignment was eye-opening and it helped me visualize what it might have been like for homo erectus, neanderthals, and homo sapiens.
I'm going to review the experiments separately, as laid out in the guidelines.
ReplyDeleteGood discussion on the issues of power in the conversation, attitudes of the speaking to the non-speaking and finding real examples of this in our own culture.
"If my sister represents a culture that uses spoken language and I represent a culture that doesn’t, that means she has most of the power without a doubt."
Agreed, but that wasn't the question. Which culture would have the advantage of communicating complex ideas within their culture?
"There is this underlying lack of respect and consideration to a culture that is unable to express themselves using spoken language. "
Yes, there is, isn't there? Why is that? Why do we seem to associate the ability to communicate with value and intelligence?
Missing the real life example that mirrors the first experiment? Try to follow the prompts and shape your post per their organization to reduce the risk of my missing where you address each point.
I don't disagree with your conclusions regarding the information we receive from body language, but you are only considering the situation where body language matches and supports the information you receive from spoken language. What does it tell you when the body language doesn't match the spoken language? Humans tend to use body language as a type of lie detector. If spoken words don't match with the body language, we are more inclined to believe the body language and doubt the words. Think about how being able to detect liars might help an individual's ability to survive and reproduce (which applies to the next section).
Okay on the benefits of body language, but what type of benefits do you get by being able to detect liars?
Great last section. Yes, those in the autism spectrum are an excellent example of those who have difficulty reading body language. You also present an great example of when reading body language might cause problems when encountering another culture that uses a different system of body language. Good discussion here.